An Imminent Threat: The State Plans for CBR Disaster While Counties PuntPermalink +
Mon, Aug 25, 2014, 11:48 am // Terry Wechsler
An article in the July issue of Whatcom Watch, Washington’s Crude Awakening, describes the status of the four area crude-by-rail (CBR) proposals at the Skagit and Whatcom County refineries. Only one of the four, Shell Anacortes, has not yet been permitted. In May, I published on NWC a comment and argued the state must step in and assume lead agency status. That is particularly true now.
The 2014 state budget included one-time grants for the state to address Bakken crude-by-rail movement in the state. The grants were for:
- $652,000 to develop geographic response plans (GRPs) for inland areas and hiring additional marine and rail experts.
- $300,000 to produce a Marine and Rail Oil Transportation Study that will analyze the risks to public health and safety, and the environmental impacts associated with the transport of oil in our state.
The governor tasked the Department of Ecology with conducting the study in a June 12 Directive “to analyze the risks to public health and safety, and the environmental impacts associated with the transport of oil in Washington state.”
This study is, in essence, a limited environmental impact study (EIS) of risks associated with shipping Bakken crude by rail and vessel. The study’s scope specifically includes the intersection of rail and marine facilities including the Puget Sound refineries, including Shell Anacortes.
Yet, Skagit County Planning and Development Services (SCPDS) just issued its second “modified” Mitigated Determination of Nonsignificance (MDNS), concluding there were no significant adverse impacts that could not be addressed with conditions on the permit.
There are numerous problems with the MDNS:
- It assumes state and federal permits will address activities and impacts without an analysis; and
- Its conditions on rail and vessel traffic are almost all voluntary, and there are no monitoring or enforcement provisions associated with any conditions.
The biggest issue is that the modified MDNS does not specify a number of trains. Theoretically, at face value, the MDNS could grant Shell permission to receive its entire refining capacity by rail.
Shell’s original permit application, in Sec. 6a stated, “The facility is being designed to receive a maximum of six unit trains per week, for a total of approximately 612 incoming fully loaded oil cars and 612 outgoing empty tank cars on a weekly basis. “ However, both the original MDNS and the modified MDNS are silent as to the number of trains.
SCPDS apparently is operating under the assumption that they have no juris diction over rail traffic and, therefore, can neither limit the number of trains received by the refineries, nor even study the impacts of that rail activity.
I spoke with Brandon Black, the SCPDS planner responsible for the Tesoro Anacortes SEPA threshold determination which resulted in an MDNS, by phone on Friday, August 22. That MDNS stated, in the Project Description:
The project is intended to provide the additional flexibility of receiving crude oil by rail and will be designed to accommodate one loaded 100 car unit train every other day.
According to Black, this language does not make the number of trains a condition of that MDNS nor the permit because his agency does not have jurisdiction over the rails. When asked if he had even considered rail risks beyond the proponent’s site during the threshold determination, he stated that his agency had not because of state and federal pre-emption.
BNSF has been reporting CBR traffic to the state since June 6 of this year in accordance with a directive from the U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT). According to those reports, there have consistently been 12 crude unit trains traveling to Skagit County, and 6 to Whatcom County. Since only BP is receiving crude by rail now in Whatcom County (Phillips 66 will not complete construction of new rail infrastructure until the end of the year), that means Tesoro Anacortes is receiving 6 trains per week, or nearly double the number of trains they stated in their permit application their CBR infrastructure was “designed to accommodate.”
USDOT issued the Directive after identifying Bakken crude by rail as “an imminent hazard.” The state is spending nearly $1 million not to determinine if there is a risk, but to measure the risks, and determine what the state must do to mitigate the risks.
No one is acting as though permits for CBR proposals could be conditioned on real mitigations, such as even placing a limit on the number of trains the refineries may receive. In a phone conversation today, Leah Forbes, SCPDS planner responsible for the Shell SEPA review, stated that the public should refer to other project documents online. But the April 22, 2014, Staff SEPA Findings state merely that “crude brought in by rail would replace some supply currently brought in by ship.” While it does describe numbers of trains and unit cars in the permit application, it states that “Shell PSR anticipates that it would receive approximately” this number of trains (emphasis added).
The number of trains matters. While Shell provided a detailed vehicle traffic analysis, they did not provide a rail or vessel traffic analysis.
CBR is already overwhelming existing rail infrastructure in Washington and forcing other commodities off the rails, so there is an important economic state interest involved when other commodities cannot reach our freight and grain terminals.
What no one is talking about is making degasification of the crude before shipment a condition of the permits.
It is untenable that the state, while acknowledging and measuring the recognized risks, turns a blind eye as counties issue determinations of nonsignificance (DNS), finding there are no significant adverse impacts associated with Bakken crude-by-rail proposals, and refusing to talk in terms of concrete numbers of trains.
Ecology is to submit an interim report to the Governor and the legislature by December 1, 2014, on the 2014 Marine and Rail Oil Transportation Study, and a final report by March 1, 2015. They expect to complete a draft interim report in September, and hold public meetings in October at which the public may comment.
But long before then, we have until the 28th to demand that the state step in and assume lead status in Skagit County. Someone has got to start applying SEPA to refineries’ crude by rail proposals. Neither SEPA nor NEPA say that they apply until a proposal gets really really big and expensive. Heck, look at the GPT EIS for an example of what should be happening with CBR proposals.
What you can do:
- For all of the below, reference Skagit County Planning and Development Services’ (PDS) Modified Mitigated Determination of Nonsignificance (MDNS) for Shell Puget Sound Refinery’s Shoreline Substantial Development/Variance Permit PL13-0468
Comment to Skagit County PDS on the Shell crude by rail proposal by August 28:
- Online; or
- By mail, directed to Leah Forbes, Senior Planner, 1800 Continental Place, Mount Vernon, WA 98273.
Immediately contact the offices of the governor and the Department of Ecology asking the state to intervene as lead agency in accordance with WAC 197-11-340(2)(e), and conduct an Environmental Impact Statement that includes an analysis of the risks and impacts associated with the cumulative rail and vessel traffic associated with this proposal. That analysis must focus on impacts that cannot be fully mitigated, measuring associated costs to state and local governments in the event of a significant incident, and consider the No Action Alternative.
- Office of the Governor: Robert Duff, Natural Resources/Environment Senior Policy Advisor, Robert.Duff@gov.wa.gov
- Ecology: Scott Ferguson, Spills Prevention Section Manager, Scfe461@ecy.wa.gov
- Ecology: Dale Jensen, Director, Spills Division, firstname.lastname@example.org
- Comment now, in writing, on the 2014 Marine and Rail Oil Transportation Study online and ask the governor to issue a moratorium on state permits for all crude-by-rail proposals pending the results of the 2014 Marine and Rail Oil Transportation Study.
- Comment in person on the draft interim report on the 2014 Marine and Rail Oil Transportation Study at one of the public meetings on 10/21 and 10/23, in Lacey and Spokane. Details will follow, including information about buses, if available.
Mon, Aug 25, 2014, 11:48 am // Terry WechslerWhile the state spends hundreds of thousands of dollars defining risks of crude by rail, Skagit County finds no significant adverse impacts of a crude-by-rail proposal.
1 comments; last on Aug 28, 2014
Fri, Aug 22, 2014, 2:06 pm // Guest writerPatrick McKee of the Sunnyland Neighborhood guest-writes about the August 11 City Council slap-dash zoning changes.
2 comments; last on Aug 23, 2014
Paper Dreams in Fairhaven
Wed, Aug 20, 2014, 4:54 pm // Terry WechslerNot content with causing massive inconvenience, BNSF is now literally dumping on county residents.
10 comments; last on Aug 26, 2014
Sat, Aug 16, 2014, 3:48 pm // Guest writerJudith Green of the Sunnyland Neighborhood guest writes this brief summary of what went wrong with the planning last week.
1 comments; last on Aug 22, 2014
Fri, Aug 15, 2014, 7:12 am // Terry WechslerA massive upgrade of the Cascade [rail] Corridor has left residents stranded and the sheriff asking Washington, DC, to intervene.
6 comments; last on Aug 21, 2014
Thu, Aug 14, 2014, 3:13 pm // Guest writerSandy Robson guest writes of the need for real prosperity at Cherry Point, not a destructive short term coal port that destroys the fishing grounds.
4 comments; last on Aug 18, 2014
Tue, Aug 12, 2014, 10:52 am // Riley SweeneySome Context for the Primary Results
Mon, Aug 11, 2014, 11:31 pm // John ServaisBellingham City Council abruptly changes zoning codes to force Planning Department plan on Sunnyland residents.
7 comments; last on Aug 14, 2014
Fri, Aug 08, 2014, 10:10 am // John ServaisUpdated Wed evening. The Tuesday evening 8:20 pm Auditor report on the election is in.
5 comments; last on Aug 08, 2014
Fri, Aug 01, 2014, 8:00 am // Dick ConoboyCouncilmember Murphy's proposal is based on a complaint-based rental ordinance from Tacoma, demonstrated to do little for the health and safety of tenants.
9 comments; last on Aug 04, 2014
Fri, Aug 01, 2014, 4:47 am // Terry WechslerCarefully planned actions are rolling across the state to make the point that it's not OK to expose us to risks associated with CBR.
7 comments; last on Aug 04, 2014
Thu, Jul 24, 2014, 11:40 am // Riley SweeneyNorthwest Citizen has conducted a phone poll of likely voters, with some surprising results!
9 comments; last on Jul 29, 2014
Thu, Jul 24, 2014, 7:52 am // Dick ConoboyIn contravention of the Bellingham Municipal Code, the City Council will consider on 4 August a last minute docketing request that ignores the Planning Commission and Samish Neighborhood.
1 comments; last on Jul 30, 2014
Wed, Jul 23, 2014, 10:47 pm // Guest writerGuest writer Mike Rostron explains how Bellingham city planners played loose and illegal with planning processes.
Tue, Jul 22, 2014, 7:22 pm // John ServaisSunnlyland residents win one - after a seven year effort. Planning Department failed them and all of us.
2 comments; last on Jul 23, 2014
Mon, Jul 21, 2014, 5:30 am // Guest writerLandlords are so caught up opposing a licensing and inspection ordinance, they cannot see the upside for them in ridding the city of bad rentals.
19 comments; last on Aug 01, 2014
Fri, Jul 18, 2014, 1:24 pm // Guest writerJudith Green explains how the Bellingham Planning Department is trying to cram their plan onto a neighborhood.
5 comments; last on Jul 21, 2014
Sun, Jul 13, 2014, 2:26 pm // Terry WechslerYears after BP completed its north dock, the Army Corps of Engineers released a draft EIS and it's really really stupid.
Tue, Jul 08, 2014, 8:20 am // Dick ConoboyThe city council "persuades" the city administration to withdraw a request for an intrusive police threat warning system
2 comments; last on Jul 08, 2014
Mon, Jul 07, 2014, 6:54 am // Terry WechslerIt is time we stop allowing corporations to externalize the costs associated with their risky business practices, and demand more from our regulators who hold the keys to…
3 comments; last on Jul 13, 2014
Mon, Jul 07, 2014, 5:04 am // Guest writerGuest writer Sandy Robson breaks the story of officials from Washington treated to a coal-promoting junket to Wyoming.
2 comments; last on Jul 13, 2014
Fri, Jul 04, 2014, 5:00 am // Guest writerFerndale's most famous landmark is frequently commented on and is often in the news. Here is their side of the story.
4 comments; last on Jul 07, 2014
Wed, Jul 02, 2014, 5:14 pm // Terry WechslerOn the anniversary of the Lac-Megantic disaster, communities throughout North America rally in solidarity to remember and protest wholly inadequate government response to crude-by-rail's risks.
4 comments; last on Jul 12, 2014
Fri, Jun 27, 2014, 9:01 pm // Guest writerIn the Weekly, Tim Johnson left out three words in quoting Craig Cole - and his story misleads readers. Guest article by Sandy Robson.
11 comments; last on Jul 01, 2014
Tue, Jun 24, 2014, 10:24 am // Dick ConoboyThe Bellingham Police Department wants to purchase "threat assessment" software with federal monies. Citizen comments were vehement and negative. City Council confused.
5 comments; last on Jul 03, 2014
Tue, Jun 17, 2014, 10:18 pm // Tip JohnsonWherein the failings of a bad policy framework are revealed
1 comments; last on Jun 19, 2014
Tue, Jun 17, 2014, 7:53 am // Dick ConoboyThe possession and use of consumer fireworks are no longer permitted within the city limits.
1 comments; last on Jun 19, 2014
Wed, Jun 11, 2014, 11:39 am // John ServaisWyoming Senators and coal honchos were in Whatcom County June 10 - to hold a news conference with select reporters.
7 comments; last on Jun 20, 2014
Tue, Jun 10, 2014, 11:20 am // John ServaisBellingham Hearing Examiner, Dawn Sturwold, retires in three weeks. Successor selection is hidden from all of us.
3 comments; last on Jun 11, 2014
Fri, Jun 06, 2014, 2:07 pm // Terry WechslerPart 2: Following Ken Oplinger to California, and Home Again
4 comments; last on Jun 19, 2014
Sun, Jun 01, 2014, 12:39 am // Guest writerA Venn diagram where coal, the Endangered Species Act, Republicans, and Wyoming’s Board of Education collide.
2 comments; last on Jun 02, 2014
Wed, May 28, 2014, 3:15 pm // Guest writerA perspective by guest writer Ellen Murphy reflects on the Whatcom Watch and the threatened law suit by Craig Cole.
22 comments; last on Jun 01, 2014
Tue, May 27, 2014, 1:23 am // Wendy HarrisWhy was so little consideration given to the concept of developing the waterfront for eco-tourism?
5 comments; last on Jun 11, 2014
Mon, May 26, 2014, 7:51 pm // Wendy HarrisCity park improvements have implications on the local and global scale.
2 comments; last on May 29, 2014
Thu, May 22, 2014, 12:10 am // Guest writerWyoming is ready to try and legally force us to limit our environmental scoping for the Cherry Point coal terminal
4 comments; last on Jun 17, 2014
Sun, May 18, 2014, 11:57 pm // Wendy HarrisReckless rezones and far-fetched explanations result in more slaughterhouses and meat packing plants
3 comments; last on May 20, 2014
Sat, May 17, 2014, 2:34 pm // Riley SweeneyRiley takes a closer look at the Charter Review Commission candidates
2 comments; last on May 21, 2014
Tue, May 13, 2014, 5:04 pm // Wendy HarrisBellingham's annual water quality report indicates that city hall's propoganda machine is going strong
1 comments; last on May 14, 2014
Sun, May 11, 2014, 2:20 pm // Terry WechslerPart 1: Introduction to the Bellingham Basin’s Potential for Fracking, Earthquakes, and Earthquakes Due to Fracking
3 comments; last on May 14, 2014
Fri, May 09, 2014, 10:02 am // John ServaisThe Political Junkie for Whatcom County - that would be Riley Sweeney - has Overstreet not running for reelection in the 42nd.
1 comments; last on May 13, 2014
Fri, May 09, 2014, 6:10 am // Terry WechslerWhy Washington must step in and assume lead agency status in Skagit County for the Shell crude by rail proposal.
6 comments; last on Jun 21, 2014
Tue, May 06, 2014, 5:52 pm // Riley SweeneyThe value of a Precinct Committee Officer . . .
1 comments; last on May 07, 2014
Mon, May 05, 2014, 3:34 pm // Tip JohnsonWherein the gyrations of the bid for widespread county slaughter are exposed.
2 comments; last on May 07, 2014
Thu, May 01, 2014, 10:21 pm // Guest writerMove to Amend is a national movement to amend the U.S. Constitution and define persons as people and speech as not money.
7 comments; last on Jun 02, 2014
Wed, Apr 30, 2014, 8:20 am // John ServaisRiley posted this morning that Seth Fleetwood has decided to challenge Doug Ericksen for state senate in the 42nd District.
1 comments; last on Apr 30, 2014
Mon, Apr 28, 2014, 6:28 am // Dick ConoboyEvery Bellingham Planning Commission member has ties to development or development-related businesses.
4 comments; last on Apr 30, 2014
Mon, Apr 21, 2014, 1:59 pm // Terry WechslerA closer look at Whatcom County's industrial "stewards of the environment."
4 comments; last on Aug 28, 2014
Mon, Apr 21, 2014, 11:43 am // Wendy HarrisThe public needs to support city council and request that a waterfront habitat assessment include terrestrial species and habitat connectivity.
Sat, Apr 19, 2014, 2:57 pm // Terry Wechsleror How Not to Plan for Future Generations' Water Needs
12 comments; last on Jun 30, 2014
Thu, Apr 17, 2014, 10:40 am // Riley SweeneyA simple explanation of the Charter Review and analysis of District only voting
Wed, Apr 09, 2014, 9:07 am // Riley SweeneyCity pushes for Alabama Street improvements, residents speak out
3 comments; last on Apr 14, 2014
Sun, Apr 06, 2014, 4:29 pm // Guest writerBy Christopher Grannis: Wherein despite every effort and expense, citizens cannot make the City follow the law or work for neighborhoods
2 comments; last on Apr 07, 2014
Sun, Apr 06, 2014, 12:52 pm // Terry WechslerWhy commenting on the EIS for Comp Plan revisions for Cherry Point means demanding an EIS in the first place.
5 comments; last on Jun 25, 2014
Wed, Apr 02, 2014, 6:00 am // Dick ConoboyAmbling University Development Group pulls out. University Ridge will not be built.
12 comments; last on Apr 06, 2014
Tue, Apr 01, 2014, 1:27 pm // Wendy HarrisPlease help us protect county wildlife by ensuring that the scope of the EIS review is adequate. A sample scoping letter is included.
Mon, Mar 31, 2014, 2:23 am // Wendy HarrisThe public has a week to comment on the scope of issues reviewed under the EIS.
Fri, Mar 28, 2014, 1:32 am // Wendy HarrisOn March 26, 2014 the city and county provided their update and assessment on the status of Lake Whatcom. This is mine.
2 comments; last on Apr 01, 2014
Wed, Mar 19, 2014, 10:32 am // Riley SweeneyRiley digs into the county's plan to buy the county morgue
3 comments; last on Mar 24, 2014
Mon, Mar 17, 2014, 12:52 am // Wendy HarrisThe public is not provided with a proposed plan or adequate information prior to the annual "state of the lake" meeting
4 comments; last on Mar 18, 2014
Sat, Mar 15, 2014, 1:11 pm // Tip JohnsonWherein there's a crackdown on growing plants, and plans to let slaughter run free
2 comments; last on Mar 16, 2014
Election InfoCandidate Filings
Primary election results
Coal, Oil & TrainsCommunity Wise Bellingham
Powder River Basin R. C.
Local Blogs & NewsBellingham Herald
Bham Herald Politics Blog
Bham Politics & Economics
Friends of Whatcom
Get Whatcom Planning
League of Women Voters
Western Front - WWU
Local CausesChuckanut Community Forest
City Club of Bellingham
Futurewise - Whatcom
Lummi Island Quarry
N. Cascades Audubon
NW Holocaust Center
Reduce Jet Noise
Salish Sea Org.
Save the Granary Building
WA Conservation Voters
Port of Bellingham
US - The White House
WA State Access
WA State Elections
WA State Legislature
Weather & ClimateCliff Mass Weather Blog
Nat Hurricane Center
Two day forecast
Watts Up With That? - climate
Edge of Sports
Famous Internet Skiers
Good Web SitesAl-Jazeera online
Foreign Policy in Focus
Innocence Project, The
Intrnational Herald Tribune
Julia Ioffe/New Republic
Middle East Times
New American Century
Paul Krugman - economics
Personal bio info
Portland Indy Media
Project Vote Smart
Stand for the Troops
Talking Points Memo
The Crisis Papers
War and Piece
NwCitizen 1995 - 2007Early Northwest Citizen
Quiet, Offline or DeadBellingham Police Activity
Citizens of Bellingham
Cordata & Meridian
Facebook Port Reform
N. Sound Conservancy
No Leaky Buckets
Protect Bellingham Parks
The American Telegraph